oh shit. i read about 3/4 of that really long review and just gave up because it was well-written and researched and i'm not of sound mind enough to combat it. my intellect is shot. i like to doodle and write silly poems, you know. i would just say to take in all sources you can and try to form an opinion as best you can. for what? well, i don't know anymore... so you can know that america is not always right and neither are strong, highly intelligent critics of america like chomsky. so nobody is always right, nor am i. the fact is, "my country right or wrong" is an untenable position. nationalism is a fabrication, a wet dream of those who seek to control our minds... once upon a time colonization was a concrete action - now the media and the powers behind them are vying for our minds and we have to be sure that we can think freely for ourselves. this is what i get from chomsky even with his potential shortcomings.
yet we enjoy various (somewhat eroding) freedoms in america perhaps because of our involvements abroad. i don't know how to account for this so i will just take another sip of my whiskey. an open mind is essential. i try to have one whether or not i can trust the elite, sweater-vested counterpoints to the official U.S. narrative sold to us by the media (conservative or not it all ends up propping up the establishment in the end). there's something to be said about the power structures of our world always ending up being reinforced whether through consent or dissent and i think, in the end, Chomsky - who is completely successful and also RICH - is a great example of how dissent can also be used to make someone wealthy and therefore somehow paradoxically reinforce the power structure already in place. i think Foucault has writings on this but i haven't been in college in a while and i only read fiction now so i can't tell you for sure.
anyway, thanks for posting. my mind has been f*cked by that review.